Royal Caribbean Penalized For Missing Video In Death Suit

A Florida federal judge has penalized Royal Caribbean Cruises Lltd. for destroying surveillance footage in a wrongful death suit over a toddler’s fall out a window. Chloe Wiegand was only 18 months old when she fell to her death from the open window of the cruise ship stationed in Puerto Rico.

In an order filed Wednesday, U.S. District Senior Judge Donald L. Graham agreed that Royal Caribbean’s decision to destroy footage rather than handover to the toddler’s parents was done in bad faith to deprive the Wiegands of evidence.

“This conduct indicates the defendant’s intent to deprive plaintiff of the requested footage,” Judge Graham wrote. “Such blatant disregard for the Rules of Civil Procedure cannot be tolerated.”

According to the suit, 18-month-old Chloe Wiegand was on the Royal Caribbean Cruise with her parents and grandparents. Her parents handed her to her grandfather Salvatore Anello. He then lost his grip on Chloe and she fell to her death.

The judge did not decide on what form the sanctions would take, saying that the “severe” sanctions the family requested were not appropriate given the loss of the footage did not impact the outcome of the case. But he said appropriate sanctions or remedies would be issued after the case is concluded through appeal, at which point the parties should submit briefs as to what those sanctions should be.

At BoatLaw, LLP, we are proud to represent clients injured aboard cruise ships. If you or a loved one has suffered injuries or a wrongful death on a cruise, our maritime injury attorneys will begin fighting for maximum compensation in your case today. Your first consultation is free, so call 1 (800) 262-8529 today and schedule yours.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • The Maritime Law Association of The United States
    The Maritime Law Association of the United States (MLA) was founded in 1899. Its formation was prompted by the organization, some three years earlier, of the International Maritime Committee.
  • Washington State Bar Association
    The Washington State Bar Association operates under the delegated authority of the Washington Supreme Court to license the state's nearly 40,000 lawyers and other legal professionals.
  • Oregon State Bar
    The Oregon State Bar is a government agency in the U.S. state of Oregon. Founded in 1890 as the private Oregon Bar Association, it became a public entity in 1935 that regulates the legal profession.
  • Alaska Bar Association
    The Alaska Bar Association is a mandatory bar association responsible to the Alaska Supreme Court for the admission and discipline process of attorneys for the State of Alaska.